Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Race to race forward

According to the text, race is considered a primary aspect of personal identity.  I agree with the author who says that in the United States, many people of non-white races use their race and culture to define who they are.  In order to determine if it’s useful to do so depends on what aspect we are trying to measure (of a person).  Can we say that all Latinos are great at math or all Caucasians are great at driving?  No, of course not.  But, in the context of cultural values, I think we can find accurate (and debatably useful) descriptions that tie race and identity.  But, even though this may sometimes be true, it’s not always true.  People, regardless of their race are individuals and should be seen as such.  Overall I think drawing conclusions about how someone will behave or should behave is a mistake; for this reason I don’t think the Census Bureau should ask anything about race.  There is no special gene that one race has that another race doesn’t.  Therefore, race, relating to potential or identity I think is irrelevant.  If anything, I think trying to connect one’s race to their individual identity can end up holding them back, not moving them forward.

3 comments:

  1. Hello Dr. H,
    I totally agree that race shouldn't be related to someones identity, even though a lot of people will refer to race to describe them. Who a person is really has nothing to do with race. It might help to understand where their family came from in a historical context but not to identify someone. Stereotypes might be entertaining to some but they don't really classify who someone is and most stereotypes aren't true. To include race into the Census Bureau can be helpful for minorities but having to choose only one race means that it kind of irrelevant because people are more than one race today.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That is a very interesting point on the Census Bureau. What do they get out of knowing the race of others? It just becomes a statistic on the board, and will cause people to generalize even more. After reading your blog post, it makes me agree with this idea of taking race off of the Census. By putting it in the Census we could be implying something when the statistics are released? "20% of Chinese are in the middle class? Chinese must be rich!" ... that may be very literal but something to that effect could happen from these surveys. It could really hold someone back, or make people draw to conclusions.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree that race shouldn’t affect how you see someone as an individual. What his or her race is should be nothing more than a detail about them, not who they are. That is not to say that a person can’t be affected by what their heritage. If someone was raised in an environment that stressed the importance of their background and the culture behind it, then their race could play a large part in how they see themselves. However, it would be misguided to assume that everyone of a particular race would act a certain way. Having expectations of someone based on their race is at best only ignorant and insensitive, at worst its prejudice.

    ReplyDelete