Sunday, February 19, 2012

Words are powerful tools

I found the section on how language defines us most interesting (and important) in chapter 4.  The text notes that language shapes our perceptions about others, and that we tend to label people by certain qualities that a person possesses.  We may define someone by their profession (he or she is a doctor or teacher) and therefore we end up interacting with that person specifically relating to how we’ve defined them.  This leads to totalizing – where we only see that person as the one label that we’ve identified them with.  The danger is that we end up leaving out all other aspects of the person, and don’t really get to know a person fully.  This is dangerous especially when groups are defined this way, such as handicapped persons or the transgender community.  When we label by only using one aspect of a person’s identity, we completely miss the whole of the person.  Likewise, the way we speak about people also shape how others view them and reflect our opinion of them.  If I like someone, I may describe their cleanliness as organized; but if I don’t like them, I may refer to their cleanliness as obsessive.  Words are powerful tools and we should all be more thoughtful about choosing them carefully.

Saturday, February 18, 2012

Hate speech is wrong but also a right

In the United States, hate speech is protected under the First Amendment.  Unless the speech can be classified as libel, obscenity, or fighting words, speaking derogatory and hurtful words is legal.  In general, hate speech applies to the use of negative words to single out and embarrass members of a particular group.  Efforts to stop this kind of language are difficult because under the First Amendment, everyone has a right to say whatever they want about anything.  And although I think hate speech is wrong and should never be engaged in, I do think we must uphold the First Amendment and allow it.  As the text points out, words are powerful and completely shape who we are and how we think about ourselves.  So, while there is no question that hate speech is damaging (and I would argue also that it’s also damaging to those who hear it, even if not engaging in it), having the choice to say certain things is inherent to the freedom that America is built on.  I would rather have the freedom to say whatever I want, than have a government body enforce limitations and standards on me.  The problem is that with freedom comes responsibility; so while we have the freedom to say whatever we want, some people don’t also accept the responsibility of how exercising their freedom imposes violence and other consequences on our society.  The best thing we can do to prevent hate speech is to educate our children about how it destroys and puts barriers between people; I believe that people use hate speech because they are uneducated.  Case in point, I have never seen anyone with any true education engage in hate speech.  Therefore, I don’t think we need to focus on banning hate speech, but our focus should be on education.  If enough people are educated, I believe we’ll see the amount of hate speech decline, while still being allowed the choice to say whatever we want.

Friday, February 17, 2012

Be yourself but not too much so

I think that both metaphors (melting pot and Jesse Jackson’s references) fit within American culture.  Yes, it is true that we have so many cultures - different and vibrant  – acting much like a quilt or a rainbow, standing next to each other, identifiable only by their differences.  But, the melting pot metaphor works too.  In America, in order to reach a height of big success, power and influence, there is an element of conformity one must have in order to succeed.  It is rare to see someone successful who has not lost at least some of what makes them unique in order to become more like the status quo.  For a couple centuries we only had white, U.S. presidents; but even with the election of Barack Obama, plenty of people have said that he was only elected as a black man, because he was able to conform and “act” white.  I am not making a judgment on this statement, just pointing out that it has been said.

So, yes, I think America both celebrates the unique tapestry of its citizens, but also punishes that very uniqueness, by only allowing those who have managed to tone down their
"different-ness", become influential on a national scale.

Sunday, February 12, 2012

Many steps forward and a few steps back

I had the great pleasure of speaking with family members for this assignment.  What a neat experience to hear their viewpoints on how things were so many years ago. 
Both my mom and step dad were 20 years old in 1975 and 1972, respectively.  My step dad said that inter-racial relationships were considered inappropriate – especially a marriage.  He said goals for men he thinks are the same today as they were in ’72, “consume at whatever your level of consumption is,” but that the goals for women were rapidly changing.  He said the sense was that women wanted to be more than a mom and more than a housewife.  He said the attitude was, “I’m not going to grow up to be my mom.”  He noted that the general public, including 20 year olds, was much more private than our culture is today.  He said only three forms of communication existed:  letter, in person, or phone.  As a result, he said that communication was deeper and more meaningful than it is today. 
My mom said similar things.  She said that in 1975 things were really changing.  She said women had a “we can do everything” attitude and noted a commercial that aired stating “she brings home the bacon, fries it up in the pan, and never lets you forget you’re a man.”  She said that most women still stayed home and raised children, but the message was for the next generation of women, to go out and take care of yourself, without a man.  She said that attitudes towards minorities, especially African Americans were really changing for the better – she said people really began to believe that “black people could be doctors.”  As a result, she said it became much more inappropriate than it had been to make racist comments.  She noted the rise of black entertainers and how society in general began to loosen up about moral codes and old ideals.  She noted that Saturday Fever with John Travolta was a huge cultural phenomenon and set the tone for new attitudes for that generation.  That said, she said it was still considered inappropriate to be gay; she noted that if you were a female and not married and without kids into your 30s then people would think you were weird and assume you were gay – which was not considered acceptable and was not openly talked about and definitely not celebrated like it is today. 
Finally, I spoke with my husband’s grandma, who was 20 years old in 1945.  (I have no living grandparents, and she is his last one, so I could only find one person who is 40+ years older than me).  She said that the worst thing you could do as a woman would be to have a baby out of wedlock.  She noted that women were becoming more skilled than they ever had been due to WWII and the demand for workers in the armed forces.  That said, she said that the GIs returning from the war after it ended were resentful because they felt that the women were taking their jobs.  She said the expectation of a female was to get married and have children.  She said holding a job was fine, but only until you became married and with children.  She said men were expected to go to college, go into the military, or get a job out of high school.  She noted that in 1945 you did not need a college degree to get a good job.  She said that dreams and goals for women were there, but not talked about because of the lack of opportunity.  There was an acceptance of, it is how it is.  She said the freedom we have today allows everyone to make all sorts of choices and live however they want to.  One point of interest, I asked about religion and she said it was largely Christianity and that if you didn’t believe in Christianity and didn’t go to church, it was considered unacceptable and that the person needed more education to understand why they needed God. 

Today, kids (20 year old kids) have so many freedoms and possibilites that I think it can be overwhelming.  Too much of a good thing can end up being bad.  I think there is certainly more equality between men and women, and both are expected to go to college and be a contributing memeber of society.  If a women wants to have a career and not a family, I don't think it is as big of an issue (although I do think some will still raise an eyebrow).  As for goals, I think it's dream as big as you want to, because anything is possible.

All in all, a wonderful assignment – everyone should do this at some point in their life!

Friday, February 10, 2012

Chapter 2

I want to start by saying that I love Soren Kierkegaard’s quote, “to venture causes anxiety, but not to venture is to lose one ’s self.”  What a perfect statement for how I feel about my life and my pursuit of a new career at 34 years old! 
Chapter 2 is a very informative chapter about how we end up who we are, and how our primary care givers have so much to do with the way we view ourselves, and the world.  I liked how the text plainly explained how a child’s self concept is shaped through either positive or negative reinforcements beginning in infancy.  Self confidence is developed (or not developed) early and really determines if the child will fall into self-fulfilling prophecies and low self esteem, or if they will grow and thrive and feel capable of handling the ever increasing demands of the world.   Along these lines, the text notes that the role of fathers in socializing children is to push their children more to stretch and grow and that mothers are more nurturing.  I know that this is the traditional model, but more and more I think there are more fathers staying home and mothers going to work.  I know that a recent medical journal (I attached an article out of the LA Times if you’re interested) reported that men who stay home with their children actually produce less testosterone and become more nurturing.  In any case, chapter 2 really stresses the importance of quality child rearing, and surrounding children and youth with praise and that children do best with the secure attachment style.

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Race to race forward

According to the text, race is considered a primary aspect of personal identity.  I agree with the author who says that in the United States, many people of non-white races use their race and culture to define who they are.  In order to determine if it’s useful to do so depends on what aspect we are trying to measure (of a person).  Can we say that all Latinos are great at math or all Caucasians are great at driving?  No, of course not.  But, in the context of cultural values, I think we can find accurate (and debatably useful) descriptions that tie race and identity.  But, even though this may sometimes be true, it’s not always true.  People, regardless of their race are individuals and should be seen as such.  Overall I think drawing conclusions about how someone will behave or should behave is a mistake; for this reason I don’t think the Census Bureau should ask anything about race.  There is no special gene that one race has that another race doesn’t.  Therefore, race, relating to potential or identity I think is irrelevant.  If anything, I think trying to connect one’s race to their individual identity can end up holding them back, not moving them forward.

Sunday, February 5, 2012

How to be human

Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs has five phases of human evolution arranged from the most basic, such as the need for physical safety, to the most abstract, such as self actualization.  Along this continuum is a stage for belonging needs.  Within this stage, the book refers to socialization and points out that people who are deprived of human contact grow up without knowing what it means to be human.  The book points out case studies of children that were found over the past two centuries who had little human contact.  The two boys that were found in the wild could not speak and behaved like animals.  What is interesting is that the young doctor, Dr. Itard, tried to socialize one of the boys, but failed to do so, presumably because the boy was older and out of the critical years.  Another example was a boy found in India and could smell meat from 100 yards away - making his sense of smell much more sensitive than any other human.  It is something we never think about – but what we think of as being human appears to be about conditioning and not as natural as we think. 

Saturday, February 4, 2012

My husband, my friend

My husband and I have been together for 10 years, and in the early days I think we vacillated between  an I-It, I-You and I-Thou relationship.  In the very beginning, it took me time to figure out where he fit in my life, and what role he would play.  Sure I knew I liked him, but I had a long list of boxes that I needed him to check before I would really consider him as a potential boyfriend.  In this way, I think the relationship was more I-It as I was trying to determine how he best served me and my interests.  I had been living a single girl’s life (early 20s) and was not in a hurry to have serious relationship.  We talked openly about everything, even in the beginning, but my intent was always to see if his values and beliefs were a good fit with mine.  As we progressed, and I started to get to know him more, I let my guard down and began to forget about my silly list that I had initially required him to meet.  I started to see him as his own person with his own agendas and talents, and stopped thinking so much about what he could do for me.  The relationship morphed into a more consistent I-You and I-Thou relationship, and today I am more concerned about him reaching his own potential in life and achieving all that he wants.  I am his friend.  He is my friend.  We respect each other as unique, individual people.  We talk about the same things that we always have, but now I view our discussions through an entirely different lens.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Types of Communication

Linear communication refers to one way communication, in which there is a sender and a receiver.  In theory, the signal (the message) will travel from the sender to the receiver and arrive as intended.  However, as with most things in life, there generally can be interruptions during this transfer of information in the form of noise.  This noise can be many things and is classified as anything that would distract either party from transmitting or receiving the message as intended.  Interactive communication is more like real life encounters where the sender and receiver both participate in those roles, simultaneously.  This exchange of information is based more on an active feedback system and is fluid. 
Linear communication could be in the form of watching television; the news anchor that is talking at me is the sender of the message and I am the receiver as the viewer.   It is a one way street.  By contrast, interactive communication is everyday conversation, even non-conversations, like communicating with pets.  I certainly send my cat messages when I am talking to him, and even though he doesn’t talk back, he communicates with me through his body language and vocalizations, responding to my body language and vocal tones.   He is, interacting with me.